Saturday, 28 March 2009
Week 9, What difference to all this might the 'digital divide' make?
a) To socioeconomically related access issues within a society?
It is evident that people who are more computer literate are going to look the best on paper when it comes to applying for jobs. But does this mean they will be any good at the job as a whole? I know that when my dad started work at 18 all he had were his O-levels and at that time computers werent even an issue therefore he had no hands on experience. Whereas now he is able to complete spreadsheets, emails and do graphic desgins online everyday with his job. Many companies argue that it costs to much time and money to train people these days which people say they dont have much of. But if we are to try and close this digital divide, how will it be possible without the backing of companies which play the most important roles in the divide?
b) To global access issues across countries and regions?
Britain is one of the wealthiest countries along with America and Japan and therefore these countries can afford technology such as computers and mobile phones. Overall it makes relations between these countries better as it is easier to communicate with the technology we posess. But in parts of, for example, Africa dont even have enough money to feed and clothe themselves nevermind buy the latest mobile phone. Also with the language barrier I think this is possibly where the greatest digital divide comes into play. Hopefully in the future with funding places like this can get the technology they need to increase communication and put them on the map. I dont mean this in terms of geography but the fact that they could then get involved in world projects which would be the best thing for their economy. Can the internet really be called global when so many parts of the world don't have access to it??
Friday, 27 March 2009
Week 9, Should education 'stretch a person do you think?
Prensky argues....
“like all immigrants, some better than others – to adapt to their environment, they always retain, to some degree, their "accent," that is, their foot in the past. The “digital immigrant accent” can be seen in such things as turning to the Internet for information second rather than first, or in reading the manual for a program rather than assuming that the program itself will teach us to use it.”
To educate a digital immigrant I think a person should not be stretched educationally because if you are not familiar with the internet things need to stay simple. Then again, if people are expected to get to grips with computer games, podcasts and the like, why shouldn't they be expected to get to grips with 2hr lectures and 500page text books?
Week 9, 1 How might Wenger's notions on practice communities relate to Prensky's on education?
Wenger talks about hierarchy amongst group members but ultimately there is an equal element of give & take, he expresses the need to educate together and he is describing a learning process in which the community take part.
Prensky speaks about how we as individuals interact with technologies & how these may aid or hinder our education. To a native anything is possible on the internet but to an immigrant getting to grips & the pace of looking up information for our on means maybe a little more difficult.
Ultimately, the internet is a tool which we can use to educate ourselves, whether that is taking advantage of methods such as search engines which is perhaps Prensky's idea or whether we join a forum or communicate with eachother in general to find what we want we need to know which is Wengers cofp side.
In my opinion, interaction seems to be a key part in any education environment whether it be in a classroom or online. Do we learn better by interacting with technology (Prenskys theory) or by using technology to interact with others (Wengers theory)
Week 9, How does semantic web differ from web 3.0?
To take the Web to the next level -- to move from Web 2.0 to Web 3.0 -- the information in online documents will have to be turned into data that a machine can read and evaluate on its own. Computers will then be able to take over tasks we now do by hand such as look up maps, book flights, and buy CDs.
I can be thought of as the difference between two dimensions and three dimensions. "People will see the Web start to become smarter," Spivack says. "Eventually it will have some reasoning capabilities built into it."
The writers of “The Semantic Web” explained that, when much of the information on the Web is encoded in such a way that it can be processed automatically, software agents will be able to perform complicated tasks on behalf of users, like booking a doctor’s appointment that fits a person’s schedule and health plan.
http://www.straight.com/article-209322/webs-future-matter-semantics
Week 9, Semantic Web
Tim Berners-Lee, the inventor of the World Wide Web defines the semantic web as “a web of data that can be processed directly and indirectly by machines.” (Altova.) In his view, all the data available now on the World Wide Web will be 'read' by machines, which will be in a 'language' only the world wide web can read and process. This makes the data accessible to machines, which in turn will make the World Wide Web easier to use for humans.
Altova (2005 - 2009) 'What is the Semantic Web?' Altova Library, http://www.altova.com/semantic_web.html [Accessed 19/03/09]
Online Brainstorming
Although online brainstorming was convenient for all of us, there were some limitations of it. Because it was online you had to take turns to say something, and often the flow of conversation was out of sync. This sometimes made conversations confusing. We each used different fonts meaning it was easier to tell who was saying what, but it was still confusing.
When discussing ideas in 'meat space' you would be able to use a different tone of voice, or way of putting across your ideas so that people understood them in the way you intended. Discussing online made this difficult as things such as tone of voice weren't available. This made it more difficult to discuss ideas than it would be in 'meat-space'
Tuesday, 24 March 2009
Week 9, 'Neo-luddites'
Another thing that might make a Neo-Luddites university life difficult is communicating with other students. Most students use mobile phones and social-networking sites such as facebook to keep in touch with and communicate with peers. Again something which a neo-luddite would find difficult.
Personally, without technology, I don't think I would survive at university. Not only with the course itself, typing up essays, using the internet for information, and blogging for online units such as this but I e-mail tutors or family and friends on a daily basis, as well as using Facebook to keep in touch with people. For me I think it would be impossible to be at university without the use of technology.
Monday, 23 March 2009
Person You Know Who Threatens the Notion of Immigrants and Natives
Personally, the person I know who most threatens Prensky's notion of 'digital immigrants' and 'digital natives' is my Grandma. She easily and happily uses text messages, uploads holiday photos to a computer, and can e-mail. She taught herself most of this, by reading the manual and using previous knowledge.
She often text messages telling me what she's upto and asking how I am, yet she will still write letters and postcards.
The Youngest Digital Immigrant I Know
He can manage to text, but it is often just to reply saying things like 'ok' or 'yes' and it takes him a while to type it.
The Oldest Digital Native I Know
I often communicate with her via social networking sites and text, as opposed to by letter, or by phone, making her the oldest digital native I know.
Thursday, 19 March 2009
Week 8, Task 2 and 3, Website 5
Digital Native or Digital Immigrant, Which Language Do You Speak? ' by Brad Cunningham http://www.nacada.ksu.edu/clearinghouse/AdvisingIssues/Digital-Natives.htm
Sunday, 15 March 2009
Week 8, Task 2 and 3, Website 4
http://coe.sdsu.edu/eet/articles/digitalnatives/index.htm
Week 8, Task 2 and 3, Website 3
The third website I am going to look at is one from the University of North Carolina. Being a university website, it is a fairly reliable source, yet this site was created in 2003 which may mean it lacks relevance to today. The website refers to Marc Prensky and Timothy VanSlyke who seem to be major thinkers in terms of digital immigrants and natives. The website has argues Prensky's view and then uses a counterargument to present both sides of the topic.
http://technologysource.org/article/digital_natives_digital_immigrants/
Week 8, Task 2 and 3, Website 2
This website is a wikipedia website which is updated often, meaning it's nearly always up to date. Although this is an advantage of a wikipedia website, the content is not always reliable which is a limitation of the website. The website is easy to use, with lots of links to other information on the subject of digital natives and immigrants, yet it lacks evidence and examples which could perhaps make it even less reliable.
http://www.digitalnative.org/wiki/Main_Page
Week 8, Task 2 and 3, Website 1
Identify five different websites/five-pages-on-different sites dealing with digital immigration and its counterpart. In your blog criticise each website in terms of up-to-dateness, usability and practicing what it preaches.
The first website I am going to analyse is written by Marc Prensky who sees a digital native as someone who has grown up, matured and been educated through technology in a digital age. The article was written 8 years ago, and therefore it's relevance to today may be limited. The website is easy to use and is phrased in a way that most people can understand. Although this website has some strong points, there is not a lot to back up the arguments in terms of evidentiary support.
http://www.marcprensky.com/writing/Prensky%20-%20Digital%20Natives,%20Digital%20Immigrants%20-%20Part1.pdf
Week 8, Task 1,
Friday, 6 March 2009
Online Learning Website
An advantage of Learn Direct is that students can also go to centres where they can talk to a 'real' person rather than just a computer, or sent material in the post. I think this is a bonus when distance learning as it feels like you're not learning entirely on your own. Another advantage is that many of the courses are available for free to many students, as funding is often available. This is helpful for people who do not have the financial means to pay for the courses, and therefore makes the courses available to everyone with access to a computer.
A disadvantage of using Learn Direct as a distance learning programme is that you need to have a Learn Direct centre near you. When I entered my home postcode to see how far a centre would be from me, it was 4 and a half miles away. This means transport would be needed for a lot of people to study, making it a limitation of studying with the Learn Direct programme.
http://www.learndirect.co.uk/
Week 7, Distance Learning in Africa
Although E-learning helps a lot of people, questions about the quality of the education that the students are receiving could be asked. The internet throughout this course means the produser is able to build on the subjects as they wish. The idea of E- learning criticises this because the mass media are just being sent messages to do with education and are expected to learn them in order to pass a qualification. There is then the problem of whether the user questions the information or just learns it as it is written.
Another issue with E-learning is what if someone doesn't understand. How much help is available to them?
Despite these criticisms E-Learning for a country like Africa is allowing some people to have a quality learning which may not have been possible before. People in rural areas are now able to connect to the internet and learn, whereas before they had been over looked by the education system. I personally think that even though there are some criticisms and limitations of the system, it is still educating people who previously didn't have access to a decent education, making E-learning a successful scheme.
Week 7, Distance Learning in China
According to the article there are four kinds of television classes: classes run by local government bureaux, classes run by factories and mines, classes run jointly by medium-sized or small work units and classes run by local TVUs at various levels to cater for fresh secondary-school graduates waiting to be assigned jobs.
It is imperitive that TVUs adopt textbooks used in conventional universities and to choose academics with a university teaching background as presenters, so that a high standard of tuition can be guaranteed. These two measures have proved to be effective.
There is a question of how much TVU's cost, and are they effective. The amount of budget varies from place to place because of the unbalanced economic development in different parts of the country. It is also important to note that in general, TVU students are free from tuition fees except free viewers and listeners who have to pay for registration and examinations. This encourages more people to use TVU's as it is so much cheaper than studying at a college or university.
Week 7, Lecture Notes
With things like Open University courses, you can study at your own pace in your own time, and contact your tutor if you are struggling. Although I see this is a good idea and is often successful, I'm not sure this type of learning would work well for everyone. In my personal opinion, having seminars and discussing work with other students is just as important as learning the work itself. You see other people's opinions and view things from other angles you may not have considered.
Even though learning online creates a new online community, I, personally, prefer learning in more traditional ways, as you not only learn the set work, but with things like group work you learn social skills and how to communicate and work with eachother. Looking at what Evans said about reading other comments helps to 'confirm your understanding or modify it in the light of new information,' he seems to think that this is a successful way of discussing ideas. Personally, I think face to face discussion is a lot more successful but I can see this is a decent alternative when studying online.
Sunday, 1 March 2009
Website Analysis
The site states the name of the football club in large font at the top of the webpage and has main news headlines in the centre of the page, with a relevent picture. There is also a link to a video piece with a report from a player about a recent match or recent news. This shows a 'multi-linear' experience. With not just text but video as well.
The links to these other pages have links have links themseleves to other sites, which Lister would describe as being 'Hypertext'. 'We may define a hypertext as a work which is made up from discrete units of material in which each one carries a number of pathways to other units' (Lister pg 24)
There is also a countdown in the top corner of the page which counts down til the next match. The colour scheme of the page is relevent as it is all in Aston Villa colours, claret and blue.
On a cultural level, the site functions as a place where fans and people interested in the club can find out about it. This in a way, creates a sense of community, with fans knowing the news and discussing the club with friends and other fans. However, expanding on what Turkle's said about computers - 'computers are not just changing our lives but changing our selves.' Instead of picking up a newspaper to find things out we can just type in a URL and get an immediate update of news. You can also watch video clips, and find links to other pages that interest you. This site is useful for me as I can find out information and results quickly and easily. If a game is being played at the time, the site automatically updates throughout, showing the score in real-time. Fans can make comments as the game plays on how they think it's going etc, which also links with Bruns' point that produsage is collaborative (2006), as it is like a forum which allow users to post under one another, or even quote someone else to build upon what has been said.
Wednesday, 25 February 2009
Week 6, 6.1, Community of Practice
Wenger claims that community of practice 'emphasizes the learning that people have done together rather than the unit they report to, the project they are working on, or the people they know.’ In terms of dancing, everyone is learning the same routines, and there is no hierarchy other than the dance teacher. This means that they can relate to one another and learn from eachother.
Monday, 23 February 2009
Week 5, Task 1 - Bruns part a).
Online gaming communities and sites such as Wikipedia can be categorised as 'produsage.' In Bruns' terms 'produsage' is "the collaborative, iterative, and user-led production of content by participants in a hybrid user-producer, or 'produser' role." (2006: 1)
A 'produser' is someone who is between production and consumption of the website or program. A 'produser' has a say in the content and can also contribute to it. Again, a good example of this would be Wikipedia.
The way 'produsers' work together is called 'Intercreativity.' The content is created by more than one person, and is done so online.Because it is done online it is interactive, and therefore this process is called intercreativity.
Bruns, A. (2006) Towards Produsage: Futures for User-Led Content Production, http://snurb.info/files/12132812018_towards_produsage_0.pdf
Wednesday, 18 February 2009
Week 5, Meikle a) and b)
Because of news being accessible on the internet, and anyone being able to publish things on the internet, it reverses the previous power structure of news. The passive audience can now contribute to the news itself, and involve themselves in producing news articles. Ordinary people with no journalism experience can now publish articles and write their own opinions about the news . But will this ever catch on? Personally, if I want to access the news online, I will visit site such as BBC or MSN to ensure that I read reports by credible journalists, so does the online news community really change what we read?
Sunday, 15 February 2009
Week 4, File Sharing Online
Music is being bought online more and more, and now, with bands being able to make and broadcast their own music online, the accessibility to new music is growing. With artists such as Lily Allen and Kate Nash becoming famous through networking sites such as Myspace, are these huge record companies still needed?
Thursday, 12 February 2009
Analysing A Web Forum
http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi?az=list&forum=DCForumID100
The forum showed the titles of the posts, the most recent one first, and the first line of each post. Under each title there was the number of message responses which each post had received. One user starts a thread, perhaps with a question, and others' messages appear to the side. The user who wrote the comment in the first place can then reply to these messages and so continue the discussion.
All members have a name. Some are perhaps real names, others obviously aren't, for example 'goldie100.' The majority of users have an avatar next to their name; usually some sort of picture but never of themselves. Although this is, to some extent, witholding their identity, it is important to consider that these people are talking to others who they don't know, and so, perhaps to some extent, have the right to withold their identity.
Using an informal language the users chat and ask eachother questions about the show. The users talk about the characters in the show as if they know them, which I found strange. The friendly tone aids the forum to appear a place of fun discussion for people with similar interests. Only a minority of users give much away about themselves or their personal lives other than their interest in the show, however it is possible to tell who is perhaps male or female due to their name, or what they are discussing.
Monday, 9 February 2009
Week4, Topic1
Friday, 6 February 2009
Week 3,Topic 1 - b) and c)
Week 3, Task 2, Part a)
In my personal opinion this depends on the extent of your identity you withhold, and in what circumstances. If you are witholding your identity simply to deceive people I think it is ethically and morally wrong. For example, if you're a white, middle-aged male, pretending to be an young, black woman, you are deceiving the person you are talking to, and also may be stereotyping which could lead to offence. In my personal opinion this is ethically wrong. However, if you don't give out your full personal details on a forum or internet chatroom then I don't see that as wrong.
Sherry Turkle argues that we now have several selves, thus it could be considered that the idea of 'self' is the same as the idea of identity. These multiple identities are changable, and 'new media', especially webforums fuel these 'selves' or 'avatars'. This means, in terms of Turkle, we can have more than one identity. Is this really so different to 'real-life?' It could be argued that on a day to day basis we adopt different identities. We act differently in front of friends than we would in front of strangers or people of authority. Is the idea of multiple identities really such a new thing?
Tuesday, 3 February 2009
Lecture Week3. Selves and Others Online
There is then the question of who we are when we are online. Are we always ourselves, or do we adopt a completely different persona? In a study of an online community, Jennifer Mnookin concluded that users 'need not in any way correspond to a person's real life identity; people can make and remake themselves, choosing their gender and the details of their online presentation' (1996) This shows that people can be whoever they want to be online, and not have to face the consequences of what would happen if they were like that in reality. This is underpinned by the names of some of the sites such as Myspace and Youtube, reinforcing the idea of being there for you to be who you want to be, whether that really is yourself, or someone entirely different.
Thursday, 29 January 2009
Lecture Week2. Interactivity.
Although there is a great difference between reading a magazine article interactively and reading a normal magazine, the idea of non-linear order, and choosing what part of an article to read, is no different to skimming over pages which you have no interest on. The ‘produser’ has the ability to choose what they read, rather than reading what the mass media present to them. I understand that media interactivity helps the 'produser' to find out information quickly and easily, yet I still prefer not to read information on-screen.
.
Week 2, Topic 1, A
Week 2, Topic 1, D
Sunday, 25 January 2009
Goebbel's Radio Speech
http://www.calvin.edu/academic/cas/gpa/goeb56.htm
Thursday, 22 January 2009
Forms of Communication on the Internet
Personally, I use email and social networking sites to communicate with my friends, and I use email to contact tutors. I use social networking sites as they are a quick and easy way to contact people informally. I use emails to contact tutors because documents can be attached and again, they are quick and convenient to use. Both of these communication forms allow the audience to be in simple and continual contact with people. I also use websites to find out information for educational purposes and also for entertainment purposes in my free time. I use websites as they are a simple and fast way of finding out information, and are usually more up-to-date than books.